Idol Thoughts

The show started by showing last Top 3 contestants and their trips home (to which I sat there going “met him. met her. met him. met him.” lol) and mentioned how they would go home as HEROES!  Now, that is a bit of a stretch…  They go home as celebrities, maybe, but heroes? Not so much, imo.

Round 1 was inspirational songs and I thought they were all kind of a mess.  I’d have to say I think Lauren did best, but that was really not saying much.  As usual, the judges failed to criticize anyone except Haley. They also showed no sign of Jimmy Iovine, but I wouldn’t doubt he was behind these performances and maybe even the song choices too.

Round 2 was the music of Lieber and Stoller and they were mentored by Lady Gaga.  I think she gave some good advice and the songs from the second round were all sung much better than the first round.  Although, James did not seem to take her advice.

Personally this week I’d like to see James or Lauren gone, but unfortunately I think it is more likely that Haley will go home because the cards are stacked against her.  She has never had a one on one stool interview with Ryan, although everyone else has.  She is the only one  that is really criticized which in a way is good to help her grow, but anyone in America who decides to vote based on the judges is probably not going to like her.  I am HOPING that America is smart enough to see that these judges are AWFUL… (I really never thought I would miss Simon – but I do!) and make up their own decisions.

I text voted 500 times for Haley tonight – I haven’t voted that much since Kris Allen… and one of my friends hooked up DialIdol to her computer and voted 700 times hands free.  Is it enough? We’ll see.

James (Don’t Stop Believing) – I like that he stopped with the antics and more seemed to just put his focus on his singing, but I didn’t think his singing was perfect by any stretch.

Haley (The Earth Song) – I think this was a weird song choice for her and she started off slow… it got better as the song went on but it wasn’t my favorite performance from her.

Scotty (Where Were You) – Not a fan of the song choice, but he did well with it.

Lauren (Anyway) – This was a great performance from Lauren

Haley (I Who Have Nothing) – Awesome performance!  Not sure if it is enough to take her to the final 3, but i hope so!

Scotty (Youngblood) – I like him better when he is doing fun songs… but I wasn’t really into this song selection.

Lauren (Trouble) – This was not a song I was expecting from Lauren and I think it was a little bit too far out of her comfort zone (and if you have such a problem with calling yourself evil then pick a different song…)

James (Love Potion #9) – I really liked this performance, definitely way better than his first song.

Category: American Idol
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.Both comments and pings are currently closed.

Comments are closed.